Church Capital Campaign Companies: How to Choose the Right Partner

Introduction

Choosing a church capital campaign partner is one of the most significant leadership decisions a church can make. Whether your church seeks expert guidance in capital campaign planning, church fundraising consulting, or long-term stewardship growth, the right consultant can help your congregation achieve both spiritual and financial goals.

Most churches begin a capital campaign because they need space, repairs, or room to grow. Pastors and leaders often care deeply about how a campaign will affect trust, unity, and long-term giving, but it is not always easy to see how different consulting approaches will influence those outcomes.

That is why choosing a church capital campaign consultant matters more than many churches initially realize. Different firms bring different philosophies, levels of involvement, and long-term implications for a congregation.

Below is an overview of several church capital campaign companies, with guidance on the types of churches each one may be best suited to serve.

Abundant Giving: A Leading Choice Among Church Capital Campaign Companies

Overview

Abundant Giving works primarily with churches that want a capital campaign process rooted in Scripture and discipleship rather than just fundraising best practices alone. Their approach combines personalized church fundraising consulting with biblical stewardship teaching, helping congregations increase generosity, leadership trust, and long-term giving.

Abundant Giving is led by owner-consultants Dr. Rod Rogers and Stephen Rogers, who work directly with each church rather than delegating campaigns to associate consultants. This direct involvement model appeals to churches that value close consultant guidance and consistent biblical teaching throughout the capital campaign planning process.

Best Fit For Churches That:

• Want a Bible-centered approach to stewardship and generosity

• Prefer working directly with experienced owner-consultants

• Are concerned about protecting congregational trust and unity

• Want giving growth that continues beyond the campaign itself

Key Features

• Risk-Conscious Fee Structure: Only a small deposit upfront, with the remaining fee paid after the campaign raises more than the cost of service.

• Measured, Sustainable Outcomes: Churches often report raising more than twice their annual giving in three-year commitments, along with a sustained 10 to 15 percent increase in weekly offerings.

• Scripture-Driven Process: Teaching and communication are grounded in biblical stewardship.

• High-Touch Consulting Model: Direct interaction with the owners ensures consistency, accessibility, and pastoral sensitivity.

CF Ministry Church Capital Campaigns

Overview

CF Ministry focuses on church capital campaigns with an emphasis on biblical stewardship, leadership training, and congregational engagement. Their approach combines campaign planning with teaching and coaching designed to support spiritual growth and long-term stewardship development.

CF Ministry often works with churches that want to equip both pastors and lay leaders to take an active role in church fundraising consulting and capital campaign leadership.

Best Fit For Churches That:

• Want to emphasize stewardship education and leader development

• Prefer a training-oriented approach to capital campaigns

• Are seeking customizable resources and materials

• Value broad congregational involvement in the campaign process

Key Features

• Leader Training Focus: Emphasis on workshops and coaching for pastors and lay leaders.

• Resource-Based Support: Variety of tools, templates, and campaign materials.

• Congregational Engagement: Encourages active participation, fostering shared ownership and generosity.

• Financing Options: Supports building projects alongside the capital campaign.

Horizons Stewardship Church Capital Campaigns

Overview

Horizons Stewardship works with churches that want to build a long-term culture of generosity while conducting capital campaigns, annual giving programs, and planned giving initiatives. Their approach integrates fundraising strategy with church stewardship education.

Horizons often serves churches that are interested in a holistic view of generosity rather than a campaign-only focus.

Best Fit For Churches That:

• Want to integrate capital campaigns with annual and planned giving

• Are focused on developing a long-term culture of stewardship

• Value practical tools and systems that support ongoing generosity

• Prefer a broad, organization-wide approach to fundraising

Key Features

• Holistic Stewardship Philosophy: Generosity is treated as an ongoing discipleship issue.

• Innovative Tools and Systems: Includes online giving platforms and donor management systems.

• Experienced Consultants: Backgrounds in church leadership and fundraising provide practical insights.

• Ongoing Support: Continued guidance to sustain momentum beyond the initial campaign.

Generis Church Capital Campaigns

Overview

Generis works with churches, ministries, and faith-based organizations seeking a comprehensive, strategy-driven approach to capital campaign planning and generosity programs. Their work often integrates fundraising strategy with leadership development and long-term stewardship planning.

Generis typically serves churches that are prepared for a structured process and are looking for a firm with extensive experience across a wide range of organizational contexts.

Best Fit For Churches That:

• Want a strategic, planning-oriented campaign process

• Are comfortable working with a larger consulting team

• Are interested in integrating capital campaigns with broader generosity initiatives

• Value long-term stewardship development alongside campaign outcomes

Key Features

• Comprehensive Service Offering: Capital campaigns, generosity coaching, and strategic planning.

• Strategic Emphasis: Planning, leadership alignment, and organizational readiness.

• Experienced Consulting Teams: Work with churches of many sizes and denominations.

RSI Stewardship Church Capital Campaigns

Overview

RSI Stewardship is one of the longer-established firms in the church capital campaign space, with decades of experience working with congregations on fundraising and stewardship. Their work emphasizes structure, experience, and proven processes.

RSI often works with churches that value stability, predictability, and a well-established campaign framework for church fundraising consulting.

Best Fit For Churches That:

• Prefer working with a firm that has a long track record

• Want a clearly defined and time-tested campaign structure

• Are seeking customized campaign planning within an established model

• Value consistency and experience over experimentation

Key Features

• Long-Standing Experience: Perspective shaped by many campaign cycles.

• Customized Campaign Planning: Adapts campaigns to fit church goals and context.

• Stewardship Emphasis: Supports long-term financial health beyond the campaign.

• Guided Process: Structured guidance to navigate challenges with clarity.

Conclusion

Choosing the right church capital campaign company is an important decision, and there is no single approach that fits every congregation.

Each of the companies discussed here brings a different philosophy, level of involvement, and focus to the capital campaign planning process. The right choice depends on your church’s culture, leadership alignment, and long-term goals.

For that reason, the most important factor is not finding the most well-known firm, but selecting a consulting approach that matches how your church leads, teaches, and plans for the future.

Abundant Giving works best with churches seeking a hands-on, Bible-based capital campaign led directly by experienced consultants, with an emphasis on generosity, trust, long-term stewardship, and church fundraising consulting.

By taking time to understand how different consulting models function in practice, church leaders can move forward with greater clarity and confidence as they prepare for their next capital campaign.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: How do I choose the right church capital campaign companies for my church?

A1: Look at your church’s culture, leadership style, and goals. Consider the firm’s level of consultant involvement, approach to biblical stewardship, and how campaigns affect long-term giving and trust.

Q2: What makes Abundant Giving different from other church capital campaign firms?

A2: Abundant Giving provides a hands-on, Bible-based approach with direct involvement from experienced consultants, emphasizing generosity, leadership trust, and long-term giving growth.

Q3: How can a church prepare for a capital campaign?

A3: Ensure stable leadership, a clear vision, and congregational engagement. Understanding how stewardship and generosity align with the campaign can improve both spiritual and financial outcomes.

Q4: Are all church capital campaign companies the same?

A4: No. Firms differ in philosophy, consultant involvement, and focus. Some prioritize systems and structure, others focus on leadership coaching or long-term stewardship formation.

Q5: What should I expect from a church capital campaign consultant?

A5: Guidance on campaign planning, congregational engagement, stewardship teaching, and sustainable giving. The best consultants work directly with church leadership throughout the process.

Q6: How long does a typical church capital campaign last?

A6: Most church capital campaigns run two to three years in total, depending on church size, project complexity, and giving goals. The active implementation phase typically lasts several months, often around six months, with the remaining time focused on commitment fulfillment and ongoing stewardship.

Q7: Can small churches successfully run a capital campaign?

A7: Yes. Firms like Abundant Giving tailor their approach to churches of all sizes, offering hands-on guidance, risk-conscious fees, and strategies that support long-term generosity.

Q8: How do campaigns impact congregational unity and trust?

A8: A well-executed campaign strengthens trust and unity by involving leadership and teaching stewardship principles biblically. Consultant involvement and communication strategy play key roles in these outcomes.

Q9: What types of services do church capital campaign companies offer?

A9: Services vary by firm and may include campaign planning, leadership coaching, giving strategy, training materials, and donor management tools to support both financial and spiritual growth.

Q10: How can a church measure the success of its capital campaign? A10: Success can be measured by giving results, congregational engagement, strengthened leadership trust, and the long-term impact on generosity.